File a Claim

To file a new claim or check on an existing claim, please contact your insurance company directly using the phone number displayed below. If you are having trouble reaching the company, or if there is not a phone number listed for your company, please contact us directly.

To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies Brown Insurance Group represents offer online claims service. Use the link in the Online Claims column below to go to your company’s online claims center.


American Strategic Insurance866-274-5677American Strategic Insurance Online Claims
Dairyland InsuranceAuto: 800-334-0090
Motorcycle: 800-325-9559
Phone only
Donegal Insurance Group800-877-0600Donegal Insurance Group Online Claims
Foremost InsuranceAuto: 888-888-0080
Others: 800-532-4221
Foremost Online Claims
The Main Street America Group877-425-2467MSAGroup online claims
MetLife888-638-5433MetLife online claims
GMAC/National General800-325-1088National General online claims
NC Grange MutualCall your local agentPhone only
Progressive800-274-4499Progressive online claims
Safeco800-332-3226Safeco online claims
Travelers800-252-4633Travelers online claims
Utica National Insurance Group800-216-1420
Utica National online claims
Victoria Insurance800-926-3168Phone only